IRONHIDE COMMUNITY FORUM

Jigou: 5
Doom Tank : 4 (+1)
Eiskalt: 15 (-2) Just to help keep things competitive.
Murglun: 7

Sirsquier wrote:Doom Tank: 5 -2 vengeance!!!

I don't even care at this point dude. My point will stand that if you're going to criticise a subject and vote it down based on is stats, then you better be able to back up your claim. You voted down Asra on superfluous information that you couldn't defend when it was questioned and then moaned that people were voting down Beresad because you liked it the most. I like Doom Tank, but I don't expect it to win because there are better heroes. So you're just wasting your vote on something because stamping your feet didn't work earlier.

Jigou: 6 (+1)
Doom Tank: 4
Eiskalt: 15
Murglun: 5 (-2)

I'm going to suggest that if we do another Elimination Game, we require a reason for each vote.

RaZoR LeAf wrote:I'm going to suggest that if we do another Elimination Game, we require a reason for each vote.

I'm totally down for that. These are meant to be discussion generators anyway from my POV. It could get very repetitive though. If it's the same reason you already posted, then I would just let it be a lone vote.

Lone vote means that people can just write one reason at the start of a thread and just leave it at that.

Maybe a half-measure of having to compare and justify your positive and negative votes? Like x is better than y because z.

AerisDraco wrote:Lone vote means that people can just write one reason at the start of a thread and just leave it at that.

Yeah, I thought of that, but decided it would go against the spirit of the rule so people wouldn't do it. Though I guess it wouldn't really now that I think about it.

AerisDraco wrote:Maybe a half-measure of having to compare and justify your positive and negative votes? Like x is better than y because z.

That's a good solution.

So a rule in two parts something like this:

You must give a reason for your votes. This is to prevent monotony and promote logical discussion. You may give a reason in one of the following ways:

A) Establish a unique reason why you prefer your vote. You may also reiterate past reasoning with added reasoning/arguments for future votes.
B) Compare your positive and negative votes. Justify why you upvoted the one and downvoted the other by juxtaposition.

Jigou: 7 (+1) - I like his design with the spears in his back and the igloo
Doom Tank: 4
Eiskalt: 15
Murglun: 3 (-2) - I dislike most dragons because they are not very unique and are usually pay-to-win, Murglun has a worse look and more boring abilities than Eiskalt imo

Umm can we wait til next time to change the rules. I kinda don't want to edit the first post. I'm lazy lol.
Also Asra has two lame abilities. The shield only lasts like 4s and the quick fire just doesn't make sense for crossbows. They are slow.

Sirsquier wrote:Umm can we wait til next time to change the rules. I kinda don't want to edit the first post. I'm lazy lol.
Also Asra has two lame abilities. The shield only lasts like 4s and the quick fire just doesn't make sense for crossbows. They are slow.

I literally said for the NEXT game. We're not changing the rules of this one, 6 pages in.

And you use logic in the weirdest way you'll overlook the dragons, the zombies, the magic, the goblins flying in zeppelins, the dwarves in mecha suits, the army of frog people and all the other unreal fantasy things, but god forbid a crossbow be shown to fire things fast when it shouldn’t?

Maybe she stole it from the Crossbow Fort, which have an attack rate of 0.5 in comparison to Asra's 1.0?

And a barrage that fired faster.

Sorry I meant the abilities. I don't have frontiers. Maybe a assassin based thing would be better.
I am sorry for being picky with weapons must read to much history.

With Honor and Contrition Sirsquier

Jigou: 7
Doom Tank: 5 (+1) - Second strongest hero here.
Eiskalt: 15
Murglun: 1 (-2) - Great concept + Underwhelming execution = Execution

Jigou: 7
Doom Tank: 3 -2 on ground can t block?
Eiskalt: 15
Murglun: 2 +1 is a dragon cool concept

Doom Tank essentially works like a flying hero. IDK why you're harping on it, especially since it CAN block as it has 3 instantly respawning units with it.

The concept I'm speaking of, Sirsquier, is Murglun's DoT focused gameplay.

Sirsquier wrote:Jigou: 7
Doom Tank: 3 -2 on ground can t block?
Eiskalt: 15
Murglun: 2 +1 is a dragon cool concept

It's a TANK. It's not Tiananmen Square, Tanks run things over.

Jigou: 8 (+1)
Doom Tank: 3
Eiskalt: 13 (-2)
Murglun: 2

The powers of Choas prevail!

Jigou: 8
Doom Tank: 4 (+1) - pretty powerful and looks intimidating
Eiskalt: 13
Murglun: 0 (-2) - same reasoning as before, might as well finish it

Jigou: 8
Doom Tank: 5 (+1)
Eiskalt: 11 (-2)

Jigou: 8
Doom Tank: 6 (+1) - Tanky Boi
Eiskalt: 9 (-2) - I’m honestly over Dragons now.

Jigou: 8
Doom Tank: 4 -2 sab
Eiskalt: 10 +1 an attack that hurts all enemies n screen

Jigou: 6 (-2) - Great hero but I can't justify him being over DT.
Doom Tank: 4
Eiskalt: 11 (+1) - I can't let my boy go down. He's the strongest hero here, is actually fun to use (the same can't be said of certain other OP heroes *cough* Beresad *cough*), and has the best aesthetics of the remaining heroes IMO.